Design a site like this with
Get started

The UK Government admitted it has no way to measure if Brexit is a success. Critics say it is a smokescreen for its failure.

  • UK government documents seen by Insider show how officials judge key policies.
  • Most have metrics that can end in success or failure, but not “seize the opportunities of Brexit”.
  • Anti-Brexit campaigners have long contended that leaving the EU will harm the UK.

The UK Government proposed no measurable way to assess the success of Brexit, according to documents seen by Insider.

Oct 7, 2021: The UK is facing chaos. With supplies of some key goods becoming scarce, the military have been called in. Is Brexit to blame?

While other priority policies were given specific targets to meet, that could be judged to have succeeded or failed, the documents did not suggest anything concrete for assessing Brexit.

Anti-Brexit campaigners said that the lack of solid criteria is an attempt to mask the ways leaving the EU has harmed the UK.

Boris Johnson’s government aspires to seize “the opportunities of Brexit, through creating the world’s most effective border to increase UK prosperity and enhance security”, according to documents published as part of the Spending Review.

Oct 5, 2021: Political Editor Gary Gibbon talks to Prime Minister Boris Johnson and asks him about his words during the 2016 Brexit referendum, immigration and labour shortages currently affecting the UK.

Instead of specific metrics, officials said they would “provide narrative reporting on progress for this outcome”.

Progress against these outcomes are to be reported to the Treasury and the Cabinet Office, the document says.

Naomi Smith, chief executive of Best for Britain, which campaigned to stop Brexit, told Insider: “The government’s bare-bones deal with the EU has so far resulted in more failure than success, so instead of moving the goalposts on Brexit, they’ve done away with them completely.

“Ministers in the Cabinet Office cannot be allowed to mark their own homework or fudge the damaging impact Brexit is having for the people and businesses who they promised only benefits.

“They must provide a clear list of priority outcomes and metrics so voters can judge for themselves whether or not Johnson has made a success of Brexit.”

This narrative-based metric is also being used by the Cabinet Office to measure the success of securing a “safe, prosperous and resilient UK”, as well as in advancing “equality of opportunity across the UK”.

Oct 1, 2021: Confidence in UK economy has ‘fallen off a cliff’

Only one Cabinet Office priority outcome, on “increasing the efficiency, effectiveness and accountability of government”, has any metrics. These metrics include the “percentage of government contracts published by departments in a timely fashion”, for which the government has been criticized.

Other departments have clearer metrics — for instance the health department is to be measured partly on cancer survival rates, and the education department will be judged in part on literacy levels in children.

No metric is suggested regarding the Cabinet Office’s handling of Freedom of Information requests, nor is there any mention in the document of transparency as a priority outcome for the UK government, aside from the Northern Ireland Office’s priority of ensuring governance in Northern Ireland is “responsive, transparent and able to deliver effective public services.”

Rhys Clyne, senior researcher at the Institute for Government, told Insider: “Without clear metrics or more information about the work involved in these areas, it is hard to gauge what success might look like for these outcomes.

“The new system does not meaningfully improve public transparency over government performance. Progress made by departments towards their outcomes will be published annually in the departments’ annual reports and state of accounts, which is a step forward.”

The Cabinet Office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Jun 30, 2016: Britain reports surge in racism post Brexit vote


Published by amongthefray

News with a historical perspective. Fighting against misinformation, hate, and revisionist history.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: